Holly ([info]several_bees) wrote,
@ 2004-03-08 20:51:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Ten points for each correctly identified title-source! Thirty points wins you a chocolate-stained te
The BBC's How Well Read Are You? quiz doesn't, alas, provide a cheerily pastable "You are Nine well read!" as part of its answers; but it does give a list of its readers' suggestions about what would make a great opening line for a book. Since I've spent a significant proportion of the last two weeks desperately rewriting the first paragraph of my thesis-novel, this seemed like it might be useful. However:

As I mounted the veranda I smelt her flesh. August's perfume smoothed upon the walls, her noises echoing down stairs like tinkling china quivering for a good tea.

Ooh, he smelt her flesh, and from a distance too. She must be all dead and rotting. That sounds like it could be fun. Oh, wait, she's making noises - maybe she's a zombie? Hey, how come my china doesn't quiver for good tea? That would be great, I could make a pot and bring it nearby and watch the china quiver in anticipation, getting all ready and excited, and then I could laugh evilly and pour the tea down the sink. "Quiver! Quiver away, my cuply friends, but you'll never get my good tea!"

She drank the bourbon like it was oxygen, not realising that her lifeline was the man who had poured it for her.

She drank the bourbon like it was oxygen. That would be "not at all", then, would it?

After the gunshot, silence, like a poultice, fell.

Given that "really inept similes" seems to be the unifying theme here, there's obviously some call for them. Maybe that's what I need to be going for. "I could see him from where I was sitting, his tinkling hair as grey as a train, glasses perched on the end of his nose like a baby eagle." "When I looked, the kitchen was empty, but the toaster was turning some bread into toast, and that toast was as brittle as a child's ear clasped to a glimmering seashell that yearned for fire." "Night fell like Rome: slowly, and with elephants."

My search for what makes a decent start to a novel also involved a bookshop, where I was unfortunately too distracted by the bagpipe rock band playing outside to come to any conclusion. I did, however, start to classify the available opening lines into attention-grabs ("All right. He's dead. Go ahead and talk to him."), descriptions of a setting or character ("A squat grey building of only thirty-four storeys."), and statements of generalisation ("The human race, to which so many of my readers belong, has been playing at children's games from the beginning."). This was useful primarily because it allowed me to spend forty-five minutes taking the verbs, nouns, and adjectives from the attention-grabs, and substituting them for their equivalents in the descriptions and generalisations. "All happy grandmothers exploded alike. All unhappy grandmothers exploded in their own way."

My conclusion, in any case, is that the best possible opening line has already been used by John Aubrey. I reach this conclusion primarily because it gives me an excuse to quote from Brief Lives again:
When Arch-Bishop Abbot's Mother (a poor Cloath-worker's Wife in Gilford) was with Child of him, she did long for a Jack or Pike, and she dreamt that if she should Eat a Jack, her Son in her Belly should be a great Man.



(Post a new comment)


[info]triskellian
2004-03-08 03:14 am UTC (link)
"Night fell like Rome: slowly, and with elephants."
I think this is a marvellous first line - I have a mental image of a god of some sort standing over the world holding the bag he keeps the night-stuff in, and he opens it and upends it, tipping out (in slow motion) a tangled mess of elephants, moon, stars, dark, and other night-things. The poor innocent people, expecting the same sort of night they had yesterday, don't realise that the god's mischievous three-year-old has hidden her pet elephants in the night-bag ;-)

(OK, it's Monday morning. I'm making my own fun ;-)

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]drquuxum
2004-03-08 06:22 pm UTC (link)
I'll withhold my embarassing score.

"Night fell like Rome: slowly, and with elephants."

Warning: pedantry alert
I didn't think Rome fell with elephants. Hannibal never made it there, and the Gauls, Goths, and Visigoths surely didn't have pachyderms at their immediate disposal...? Unless it's a metaphor for the crumbling and impotent plutocracy....

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]several_bees
2004-03-08 06:32 pm UTC (link)
Mm, but the similes in the BBC suggestions are similarly broken - that one doesn't drink oxygen; that poultices do, no doubt, sometimes fall, but not more so than anything else nor in any particularly consistent manner. Hence the elephants: a superficially compelling figure of speech that, on examination, doesn't actually work.

Though I wish it did, since I rather want to use it, now. If only Hannibal had tried just a little harder.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]drquuxum
2004-03-09 12:13 pm UTC (link)
If only Hannibal had tried just a little harder.

I know -- he kept forgetting the fava beans back then.

*crawls away at the pathetic attempt at humour*

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]kharin
2004-03-08 03:20 am UTC (link)
Hmm, I've always felt that first lines of Earthly Powers were the best possible opening.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]several_bees
2004-03-08 04:41 am UTC (link)
And, when subjected to the appropriate cross-breeding with a handy generalisation (since it's obviously an attention-grab itself), becomes "The past is a foreign bishop; they do catamites differently there."

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]kharin
2004-03-08 05:07 am UTC (link)
I feel LP Hartley would approve.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]qatsi
2004-03-08 10:23 am UTC (link)
Remarkable. I scored 8/10 on the BBC quiz, almost entirely through guesswork. And one of the ones I got wrong was one I was most confident about.

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…